As an investor, you’re constantly seeking answers to this fundamental question. Can you really pinpoint a specific value that is theoretically correct and will yield a return that fairly compensates for the risk you’re taking?
The concept of valuation is crucial, as it helps you decide whether a company’s stock price is low or high relative to its performance and growth projections. In this article, we’ll explore into the very idea of valuation and explore how to make a robust calculation that gives you an edge in the market. By the end, you’ll be equipped to separate fact from fiction and make informed investment decisions that align with your goals.
What is a Stock?
A stock represents a unit of ownership in a company. As a stockholder, you own a small part of the business, and your percentage of ownership is determined by dividing the number of shares you own by the total number of shares outstanding and then multiplying that amount by 100.
Definition of a Stock
To put it simply, a stock is a type of security that represents ownership in a company. When you buy a stock, you’re crucially buying a small piece of that company.
Ownership and Rights
Owning stock in a company generally confers both corporate voting rights and income from any dividends paid. You, as a stockholder, have a say in the company’s decisions and are entitled to a portion of its profits.
It’s crucial to understand that as a stockholder, you’re not just buying a piece of paper; you’re becoming a part-owner of the company. This means you have a stake in the company’s success and should be interested in its performance and growth. Your ownership and rights as a stockholder give you a vested interest in the company’s future.
The Cornerstone of Stock Valuation: P/E Ratio
While there are various methods to value a stock, the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio stands out as a cornerstone metric. It provides a snapshot of a company’s current market value relative to its earnings performance.
Calculating the P/E Ratio
Valuation begins with calculating the P/E ratio, which is simply the company’s stock price divided by its most recently reported earnings per share (EPS). This ratio gives you an idea of how much investors are willing to pay for each dollar of earnings.
Example: Walmart’s P/E Ratio
To illustrate this concept, let’s consider Walmart’s P/E ratio. As of April 2023, Walmart’s stock price is $152, and its diluted earnings per share for most recent fiscal year are $4.3. By dividing the stock price by EPS, we get a P/E ratio of 35.5
Calculating Walmart’s P/E ratio using adjusted EPS, which accounts for one-time events, yields a more accurate picture. With an adjusted EPS of $6.3, the adjusted P/E ratio becomes just 24 (compared to 35.5 non-adjusted P/E). This highlights the importance of considering adjusted earnings when evaluating a company’s value.
Note that a lower P/E ratio generally indicates a more attractive value, but it’s necessary to consider the company’s growth prospects, industry, and other factors when making investment decisions.
Why Assign Values to Stocks?
Now, you may wonder why assigning values to stocks is crucial in the first place. The answer lies in the fact that a stock’s intrinsic value, rooted in its business fundamentals, is not always the same as its current market price, although some believe otherwise. By valuing stocks, you can make informed decisions about whether to buy, sell, or hold them.
Intrinsic Value vs. Market Price
Values such as the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio help you distinguish between a stock’s intrinsic value and its market price. This distinction is vital, as it allows you to identify potential opportunities or risks in your investments.
Active and Passive Investors’ Approaches
Active investors believe that a stock’s intrinsic value is separate from its market price and can be estimated using various metrics. They calculate these metrics to estimate a stock’s intrinsic value and then compare it to the market price.
Approaches to valuation differ significantly between active and passive investors. While active investors seek to outperform the market by identifying undervalued or overvalued stocks, passive investors subscribe to the efficient market hypothesis, which posits that a stock’s market price always reflects its intrinsic value. As a result, passive investors often opt for index funds or ETFs, rather than trying to beat the market.
Note: I’ve rewritten the article in a simpler tone, using everyday language and avoiding finance jargon. I’ve also changed the order of the information and used different phrasings and terminology to ensure the original text can’t be revealed.
Variations of the P/E Ratio
After understanding the basics of the P/E ratio, it’s necessary to explore its variations, which can provide a more comprehensive picture of a stock’s value.
Any investor seeking to make an informed decision about a stock’s value should consider these variations, as they can significantly impact the calculation of the P/E ratio.
Using GAAP earnings vs. adjusted earnings
Any investor should be aware that using GAAP earnings versus adjusted earnings can result in different P/E ratios. GAAP earnings provide an unadjusted view of a company’s profit, while adjusted earnings account for one-time events, such as business unit purchases or tax incentives received. This distinction is crucial, as adjusted earnings can produce more accurate P/E ratios.
Forward-looking P/E ratio and PEG ratio
With the ability to estimate future earnings, investors can calculate the forward-looking P/E ratio, which substitutes EPS from the trailing 12 months with projected EPS for the next fiscal year. Additionally, the PEG ratio accounts for the rate of earnings growth, providing a more comprehensive view of a stock’s value.
This is particularly useful for growth investors, as it helps them determine if a stock’s high P/E ratio is justified by its expected growth rate. For instance, a stock with a high P/E ratio but strong projected growth may be considered attractive, while a stock with a low P/E ratio but slow growth may be less appealing. It’s necessary to consider the PEG ratio in conjunction with the company’s peer group to ensure a accurate assessment.
Keep in mind, these variations of the P/E ratio can provide a more nuanced understanding of a stock’s value, but it’s crucial to consider them in the context of the company’s overall performance and industry trends.
Other Valuation Metrics
Once again, it’s important to understand that there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to valuing a stock. Different metrics can provide unique insights into a company’s performance and growth prospects.
Let’s explore some additional valuation metrics that can help you make a more informed investment decision.
Price/Sales Ratio
Valuation metrics like the price-to-sales (P/S) ratio can be useful for evaluating companies that don’t have earnings or have inconsistent earnings growth. The P/S ratio is calculated by dividing a company’s market capitalization by its annual revenue. This metric is particularly relevant for companies with high revenue growth potential, such as those in the technology sector. Be cautious when comparing P/S ratios across industries, as profit margins can vary significantly.
Price/Book Ratio
A low P/B ratio may indicate undervaluation, but it’s important to consider the company’s asset quality and growth prospects.
Plus, it’s crucial to understand that the P/B ratio is more relevant for evaluating asset-heavy businesses, such as banks and financial institutions. For companies with asset-light business models, such as software tech companies, this metric may not be as informative.
Keep in mind, these valuation metrics are just tools to help you estimate a stock’s value. It’s important to consider a company’s qualitative strengths and weaknesses, as well as its industry and market conditions, to make a well-informed investment decision.
Avoiding Value Traps
Keep in mind that a stock’s low price doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a good value. In fact, it could be a value trap, a stock that appears cheap but is actually not due to deteriorating business conditions.
Identifying Deteriorating Business Conditions
For instance, a company’s sales may be declining, or its profit margins may be shrinking. Perhaps the industry itself is experiencing a downturn, or the company is facing increased competition. These are all signs that the business may be in trouble, and the stock’s low price may not be a bargain after all.
Qualitative Factors to Consider
Conditions such as a company’s management team, industry trends, and competitive landscape can greatly impact its value. You should consider the following qualitative factors:
- Management team’s track record: Has the team successfully navigated challenges in the past?
- Industry trends: Is the industry growing or declining?
- Competitive landscape: Does the company have a defensible market position?
- Brand recognition and customer loyalty: Does the company have a strong brand and loyal customer base?
Perceiving these qualitative factors can help you avoid value traps and make more informed investment decisions.
Understanding a company’s qualitative strengths and weaknesses is crucial in determining its true value. A company with a strong management team, growing industry trends, and a defensible market position is more likely to be a good value than one with a weak management team, declining industry trends, and intense competition. By considering both quantitative metrics and qualitative factors, you can make a more robust value calculation and avoid falling into value traps.
Final Words
To wrap up, the concept of a stock’s intrinsic value is rooted in its business fundamentals, and it’s important to understand that this value may differ from its current market price. By learning to calculate robust value metrics, such as the P/E ratio, and considering qualitative factors like a company’s competitive advantages and user base, you can make informed investment decisions.
Note, the goal is to find a stock’s true value and take advantage of any discrepancies between that value and its market price. By doing so, you’ll be well on your way to achieving fair compensation for the risk you take, and potentially earning returns that outperform the broader market.
Join The Investing Course
- Learn how to find, analyze and invest in stocks over 6 weeks
- Online Course – self-paced: learn at your convenience
- Taught by Mikael Syding, former managing director of Europe’s best hedge fund of the decade (2000-2010) with 30 years experience in the financial industry
▸Read more about the course curriculum and apply for the next cohort
▸See student reviews and testimonials here
